Will the Cameron Government Be THAT Euroskeptical?

Update: the UK government has issued a statement on a common position on relations with the EU. As expected, it reiterates the idea of future referendums on new revisions of the founding treaties. The idea of new opt-outs from the Treaty of Lisbon is discarded, however.

The deed is done, and a coalition between the Conservative Party and the Liberal Democratic Party will probably govern the United Kingdom. As usual, I try to figure out what does this mean for the European Union.

First, on the personality effects. David Cameron and the future Foreign Secretary, William Hague, are not, well, real fans of the European Union. Cameron and Hague have given some pretty worrying signals in the past. Cameron promised to run a referendum on the Treaty of Lisbon, but later backed down. He also did try to sabotage the entry into force of the Treaty of Lisbon by writing to Vaclav Klaus.

Mr. Hague, the former chairman of the Conservative Party, and future Foreign Secretary, has a motto: ‘In Europe not run by Europe’. His special breed of euroskepticism was an essential part of his strategy as a party leader, and later as a shadow Foreign Secretary. He eagerly opposed any idea of joining the euro. He went so far that no other than the White House administration expressed its concern that the Conservative’s Euroscepticism could undermine the ability of a Conservative government to influence events in the EU. However, a leaked memo in the Guardian, drafted by civil servants on behalf of William Hague, shows that he is still in the same boat. He reiterates the earlier demand by Cameron for a number of new opt-outs (criminal justice, the Charter of Fundamental Rights, and social/employment issues) that would demand new revisions of the founding treaties.

So the question is will Mr. Cameron and Mr. Hague pursue this policy in full? I am not so sure. The Cameron government will be a coalition government, to begin with. On the criminal justice front the Liberal Democrats demand keeping Britain part of international crime-fighting measures such as the European Arrest Warrant, European Police Office (Europol), Eurojust, and the European Criminal Records Information System. They also believe that it is in Britain’s long-term interest to be part of the euro. Again, on a personal level, Nick Clegg – the future Deputy Prime Minister, was a European Commission official, and later – a member of the European Parliament.

This obvious contradiction must be cleared. It remains to be seen how the new British coalition government will manage these issues. In fact, the future government’s stance on Europe may the main stumbling block ahead. Perhaps Mr. Cameron can use some wisdom stemming from the special relationship.

2 responses to “Will the Cameron Government Be THAT Euroskeptical?

  1. Pingback: In Defense of Anglophilia - Instant Cappuccino

  2. We’ve now had a few months of Cameron as PM and we know a little more about his Euroscepticism.

    One of his first acts was to close down a civil service department looking at preparation for the UK to join the euro. Preparing for the euro is now off for five years, and therefore the earliest adoption (if there is a change of government in 2015) would seem to be about a decade hence. This distances the UK from the EU’s flagship project.

    The key area is the “Sovereignty Bill” that will be introduced in the UK parliament very soon, and which has the support of the Coalition – so it is likely to become law. There are two key issues:
    1) There will be a “referendum lock” where no new EU Treaty may be passed unless agreed by the people in a referendum. And the “referendum lock” will also apply to any use of ratchet clauses or self-amending provisions within the Lisbon Treaty. Merkel’s proposed revision would (presumably) fall in this category and trigger a referendum.
    2) There will be a statement that EU law applies in the UK only when the UK parliament wills it. There has been some media speculation that this would apply also to year-by-year EU budgets, and the government has not silenced this speculation.

    This all seems rather Eurosceptic to me – what Cameron has avoided is a public disagreement with the EU or with EU heads of government.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s